Acupuncture and Infertility

Posted on August 18, 2006 by Inception Fertility

PFC patients often inquire about the use of acupuncture as a part of their infertility treatment, and, as such, PFC brings you insight from Bethany Richardson M.S., L.Ac and Leslie Oldershaw, L. Ac., two Bay Area acupuncturists who integrate fertility treatment into their practices. As background, Bethany Richardson was originally a massage therapist who took a Chinese diagnosis course while working on her Shiatsu certification. That course sparked her interest in pursuing a degree in acupuncture and led her to discover her love for science and the integration of eastern and western medicine. Leslie Oldershaw entered the field of acupuncture after spending her college years dedicated to pre-med courses. She became aware of Chinese medicine as a system of treatment while in college, and it fit perfectly with her passion for eastern philosophy and culture. She had always been interested in women's health and found that fertility treatment in Chinese medicine truly encompasses all aspects of a woman's health. Recently, PFC interviewed Leslie and Bethany about their approach to infertility, integrative medicine, and the strengths and weaknesses of acupuncture as a fertility treatment. PFC: When a patient first comes to you and cites infertility as the reason for their visit, what sort of initial work-up do you do? Leslie Oldershaw: I do a very comprehensive intake that involves an interview that takes a full medical history. Depending on their history, they may have had labwork done, or I may be ordering tests. From a fertility standpoint I like to see the basic hormone panels, including a cycle day 3 FSH, TSH, Estradiol, and also a mid-luteal progesterone test. If they have done a Clomid Challenge test, I love to see those results. If they have had a HSG or an ultrasound, I like to see that as well. From a general wellness perspective, I need to see a CBC and lipid panel and a comprehensive metabolic panel. When it comes to age, if a patient is younger we can be less aggressive. If a patient is older, we will be more aggressive. If they are 30, I will do this basic work-up, but I will be more inclined to just look at how they do over the next 6 months. If someone who is 40 comes to me, I will recommend that they consult a reproductive endocrinologist. They may want to have more of an accelerated timeline in terms of their treatment options. One of the challenges that I have is that I get patients who don't want to do the western tests. They don't want a workup, or the partner doesn't want to do a semen analysis. I spend a lot of time educating patients to make an informed decision rather than shooting in the dark. I will be more persuasive with my arguments as the patient gets older! Bethany Richardson: Normally, by the time a patient sees me they have already been to a fertility expert. I ask them to bring in their most current blood work. If they have had an antral follicle count, I want to know what that is. The basal temperature chart gives me a wealth of information. I look at it more in terms of a Chinese diagnosis, not necessarily are they ovulating or when they are ovulating, which is important, but are they running too hot or too cold. It gives me a lot of subtle information from a Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) standpoint. If I am looking at a woman who is younger, maybe 31 or 32 years old, then I look at her history of antibiotic use and if they have a history of digestive problems. I look at her menstrual cycle, her PMS, and if she is able to detoxify her hormones correctly. If I am looking at an older woman, I look and see if she is too hot or too cold. Does she have an excess of hormones? I see people mainly when they are desperate. They come to me after two cycles of IVF and want to do everything they possibly can for the next cycle. And unfortunately, I would be more effective if I saw them earlier on, but I do what I can when patients come to me. PFC: If a patient comes to you and she already knows she must do IVF or IUI to get pregnant, what type of protocols do you offer in conjunction with her fertility treatment? Leslie Oldershaw: When I work with a patient leading up to the treatment cycle, there are a couple of different protocols we can utilize. The more comprehensive protocol requires 2-4 months and allows you to incorporate nutrition, acupuncture and herbal modalities. We can do a tremendous amount to build a patient up, particularly if they are coming out of a miscarriage. We also work with patients on a shorter timeline, where they might be coming in to work with us a few weeks before an IVF cycle, and then we are primarily relying mostly on acupuncture to promote good blood flow and circulation. We will talk to the patient about nutritional support, including a pre-natal vitamin and omega-3 essential fatty acids. There is not enough research at this point to use fertility medications in conjunction with herbs. If things don't go as expected the doctor needs to be able to troubleshoot what went wrong. My feeling is that acupuncture is of benefit to everyone. The people for whom acupuncture does not work are the patients who are very needle phobic. And I have to say, my IVF patients are champs. They look at my very small needles and they scoff! Bethany Richardson: The type of treatment depends where on the continuum they are. I look at whether or not they have done IVF before, and what the results were. Were they a poor responder? How old are they? Sometimes they come to me and they tell me their IVF cycle is in three weeks. I can't do anything with herbs in three weeks, but I can do some acupuncture. If it is six weeks or eight weeks, then we will have a real protocol. From my perspective the hormones you inject are a very warm tonic, which can burn out your cooling system. Depending on how they react to the injectables, I might try to work with them to take some time off from IVF and load them up with cooling tonics. What I see then is that cervical mucus increases, sleeping patterns regulate and stress levels go down. It's hard for me to prove that it works, but I honestly believe that it does. Stress management, diet, acupuncture and IVF combined can add up to a much greater level of success. PFC: What are the strengths and weaknesses of using acupuncture to treat infertility? Bethany Richardson:**: Is there anything you want to add about treating infertility with acupuncture? Leslie Oldershaw: I have always been keen on integrative approaches. There is a tremendous amount that western medicine can do to help people achieve a pregnancy. But what makes a critical difference for me is the integrative approach. What I am doing with my patients is different than what a Reproductive Endocrinologist does, but together we can work synergistically to create the best outcome. Bethany Richardson:** I am very excited about the future. I am hoping that eventually there will be research money that is earmarked for this arena. Often times acupuncture is seen as competitive with western medicine, and I don't think it has to be. If we join forces we can be more effective together.

See all articles



      About the Blog

      Welcome to the Pacific Fertility Center Blog! Nationally and internationally recognized for providing exceptional reproductive care, our team believes in empowering people with the knowledge they need to navigate their unique fertility journeys.

      From information on the latest fertility treatments to valuable insights on egg donation, surrogacy, and everything in between, the Pacific Fertility Center Blog is your ultimate resource for all things reproductive care and support. Read on to learn more, and contact us today if you have any questions or want to schedule a new patient appointment.